Recently Josh Yohe from the Tribune Review released an article noting that Marc-Andre Fleury will likely enter the 2014-2015 season without a contract extension. Rutherford was quoted in the article by stating that “I'm not in a hurry to do a contract with him” but then almost backtracks mentioning that “there’s no reason why he can't be our goalie for a long time.”
I noticed after Josh broke this new, the reaction of fans were about as up and down as a roller coaster. Some hope he will gone and are quick to mention his flaws from years past. Some think the Penguins management has absolutely no idea what they are doing and are calling for a firing before the season even begins. I am kind of in between.
A typical MAF argument between Penguins fans can sometime go like this:
MAFFan: This can't be happening!
MAFHater: MAF sucks!
(MAF gives up 4 goals in two periods in one of the team's first 10 games....which WILL happen)
MAFFan: It's just one game.
MAFHater: What a joke! Trade him now!
(MAF has 2 shutouts in 4 games)
MAFFan: See? We can't let him go. He's elite!
MAFHater: He can't do that in April!
MAFFan: He did last April!!!!
This “argument” can go on for months. It will likely get both individuals losing because generally goalies have good games and then goalies have bad games. It has almost become a type of unrealistic expectation thrust upon Pittsburgh’s athletes. Some fans expect perfection every time.
I recently read an article arguing that Fleury is holding the Penguins back from another Stanley Cup, as if one player could ever hold back a whole team from a Stanley Cup. Newsflash: last I checked Fleury was not the Penguins biggest issue last season. I would more so cite the fact that I can name the players that showed up on one hand. Might I also mention that Fleury was one of those players.
I strongly enjoy the notion that Marc-Andre Fleury did not play well this season, or at least as well as he did the year we won the Cup. Ladies and Gentleman this should be a lesson in goggling statics before formulating arguments:
CAREER PLAYOFF STATISTICS
SEASON TEAM GP W L SO GA SA SV% GAA
2006-2007 PENGUINS 5 1 4 0 18 150 .880 3.76
2007-2008 PENGUINS 20 14 6 3 41 610 .933 1.97
2008-2009 PENGUINS 24 16 8 0 63 686 .908 2.61
2009-2010 PENGUINS 13 7 6 1 37 339 .891 2.78
2010-2011 PENGUINS 7 3 4 1 17 168 .899 2.52
2011-2012 PENGUINS 6 2 4 0 26 157 .834 4.63
2012-2013 PENGUINS 5 2 2 1 17 145 .883 3.52
2013-2014 PENGUINS 13 7 6 2 32 378 .915 2.40
NHL TOTALS 93 52 40 8 251 2,633 .905 2.68
Please look at the 2008-2009 season versus the 2013-2014. Yeah. I noticed that too. Jay-Z said it best "men lie, women lie, numbers don't" To claim Marc-Andre Fleury did not come back this season from past issues is factually incorrect. Then to compare it to the season we won the Cup is just inaccurate and gives everyone a little laugh.
I understand the frustration in years past but if you want to fight over Fleury ruining the playoffs this year or not deserving an extension please analyze the stats before you fight. After that please let me know who would be available and do a better job. Remember kids- sometimes we want a change until the change actually comes. After that we are left wishing things could go back to the way they were.
Josh’s Article is linked below and it’s a great article: